Review: The Boundary by Nicole Watson

The Boundary is a debut novel from Queensland lawyer Nicole Watson and tells the story of the aftermath of an unsuccessful native title claim made by the Corrowa people of Brisbane. Hours after handing down his judgment with respect to the claim the Judge who presided over the case is murdered and it’s not long before Police focus on the people involved with the claim as suspects. When another high-profile person connected to the case dies the claimants are even more heavily scrutinized. Action unfolds from several perspectives including that of Miranda Eversley, one of the lawyers who helped fight the six year case, and the two Homicide detectives who must investigate the murders. One of the detectives is Jason Matthews who has largely, and deliberately, ignored his own Aboriginal heritage while his partner, Andrew Higgins, is the son of a disgraced policeman.

The rather tumultuous world of Queensland politics and the public service is depicted with all its flaws on show in The Boundary. We see entrenched corruption, media spin taking precedence over real action, institutional inertia in both the public sector and the Aboriginal rights movement and the indisputable racism of the law and its application to Aboriginal people. Broader social issues surrounding the historical treatment of Aboriginal people by successive generations of European settlers and the never-ending stream of ‘solutions’ which presuppose that, collectively, Aboriginal people, even today, are merely a problem that could be fixed if only the right sequence of committee meetings held are also explored.  The anger and disillusionment that is palpable throughout the novel is perhaps best encapsulated by this reflection from the Judge shortly before his death

He can even concede that the law is unfair: in order for their native title claims to succeed, black families must somehow prove that each generation was unscathed by the carnage of the Europeans, an insuperable obstacle for those in the cities.

Although I can’t claim any particular insight into many of the individual experiences and histories depicted in this book I have, through work, had a lot to do with the processing of claims under native title legislation and have believed for a long time that, whatever the original intent, its application is appallingly inadequate and bordering on the insulting. It was therefore particularly interesting, though saddening, for me to see this reflected in The Boundary.

For all that though the book is first and foremost a story; succeeding in the main in making the narrative rather than the politics the most important part of the book. Chiefly this is because the characters we meet are well drawn, even if many are nearly as confronting as the themes of the book. Miranda struggles with self-loathing and alcoholism, feeling she can’t do enough to live up to the expectations her community and her father, a respected activist and elder. Her battle is a grim one though credibly depicted and it’s not too much of a spoiler to let on there is a welcome sense of hope surrounding Miranda despite all she goes through. The two policemen are memorable for different reasons and one in particular made me squirm. His attitude, even if not his extreme presentation of them, is worryingly familiar. The various politicians and government officials are, again sadly, all too credible; with several bearing a startling resemblance to people I know.

Some aspects of the writing in The Boundary are a little clunky, in particular a slight over abundance of similes and metaphors, but other elements suit the story even though they might not be considered strictly kosher in a grammatical sense. The use of short sharp sentences, sometimes without the prepositions one might expect, is done to good effect in helping express frustration and anger. The narrative is a little patchy in parts, there’s one sub-thread that I didn’t think added much to the overall story, but this is a minor criticism of what is an overwhelmingly believable and engaging story which also incorporates traditional storytelling in a compelling and nicely understated way.

This is one of those books that should be much more widely read than it undoubtedly will be, and the people who would benefit most from its lessons will never open its covers. Despite this, or perhaps because of it, The Boundary is a fine addition to the growing library of contemporary Australian crime fiction which examines our society intelligently and realistically while telling a ripping yarn. In case there is any doubt, the fact that the book is at times also confrontational and even uncomfortable is not meant as a criticism, just the opposite in fact, but I won’t pretend it wasn’t something of a relief to reach the last page. However necessary it may be it is unsettling to be prompted to honestly examine one’s own behaviour and potentially hidden biases. It’s been a long time since a book did that for me.

Nicole Watson is a member of the Birri-Gubba People and the Yugambeh language group. Nicole has a Bachelor of Laws from the Universityof Queenslandand a Master of Laws from the Queensland University of Technology. Nicole was admitted as a solicitor of the Supreme Court of Queensland in 1999. She has worked for Legal Aid Queensland, the National Native Title Tribunal, the Queensland Environmental Protection Agency and as a columnist for the National Indigenous Times. Nicole is currently a senior research fellow at the Jumbunna Indigenous House of Learning, University of Technology, Sydney. This is her first book; published after having won the 2009 David Unaipon Award for a manuscript by an unpublished indigenous writer.

The Boundary has been reviewed at Aust Crime Fiction

My rating: 4/5 stars (rating scale is explained here)
Publisher: University of Queensland Press [2011]
ISBN: 9780702238499
Length: 271 pages
Format: Trade Paperback
Source: I bought it

16 thoughts on “Review: The Boundary by Nicole Watson

  1. Thanks for this review, Bernadette. I heard Nicole speak on a panel at SheKilda and was very impressed by her. The Boundary will go on my reading pile at the next available opportunity.


  2. Oh, goodness, great review, but now the hassle of trying to get this over here in the States.

    Will try.


  3. Like Angela I heard Nicole speak at SheKilda and had to buy a copy, so it added to my horrendously heavy suitcase back across the Tasman. In view of the issues it covers I’m not sure I’m looking forward to reading it, but I feel compelled to read it. The panel Nicole was on also featured Malla Nunn and L.A.Larkin, and was a cracker.


  4. Wish I could have seen the panel, Sounds like a good one. The book might not be as tough to read for everyone, I just felt close to it for several reasons. much easier to see these kinds of books as intellectually interesting when they’re set in Sweden or somewhere far away, harder for me to keep distance when it’s a setting I am intimately familiar with.

    I’m very glad I read the book even though it made me squirm


  5. I just reread the review and the comments. This is undoubtedly a book I want to read, and then pass on to friends who would be quite interested in it.

    From what I see here, this is a book which will educate me about issues I know barely anything about but want to learn.


  6. Pingback: Can you catch a fish alive? | Petrona

  7. Pingback: Books of the Month – October 2011 | Reactions to Reading

  8. Pingback: A fair dinkum month – November (and some of October) 2011 | Fair Dinkum Crime

  9. Pingback: Book review: The Boundary by Nicole Watson | Petrona

  10. Pingback: 2011: The New Authors | Reactions to Reading

  11. Pingback: 2011: The Australian Authors | Reactions to Reading

  12. Pingback: 2011: The Favourites | Reactions to Reading

  13. I just finished The Boundary, and while I thought a bit of the writing was hard to follow in which you describe above, the overall messages were very important. I agree that more people should read this book, and probably those who most should read it, won’t.
    However, I’m glad I read it. I learned a lot and found parts of it very painful, as it’s based on the reality of racism, oppression and police brutality in Australia. It should be read by a much bigger audience.
    Nicole Watson has made an important contribution here. I agree with her political conclusions about movements and what makes social change.
    I look forward to her next book.
    Thanks for your incisive review which drew me to this book.


    • I’m glad you didn’t find it too impenetrable Kathy, in some ways it feels like a very local book but I’m sure many of the broader themes do transfer to other countries. I have not heard if Nicole Watson is writing any more books but I hope so

      Thanks for the kind words about the review 🙂


  14. Hi Bernadette
    Thanks for linking your crime reviews to the AWW site as I missed this one first time round. (I do remembering reading your review of YA Erskine’s The Brotherhood which went straight on my ‘to be read’ pile.)

    I’ve only recently read The Boundary and enjoyed it thoroughly. I particularly liked the fact that white characters are mostly peripheral to the narrative, and Watson depicts real diversity among the Aboriginal characters. I’m looking forward to more from her.


Comments are closed.